The Delta Issue #118

Universal Child Care Is Having a Moment. Let’s Get Specific.

Hi y’all, Jessica here.

Universal pre-K. Universal child care. Free preschool for all.

If you followed this year’s gubernatorial races, you probably heard some version of these promises on the campaign trail.

Child care has become a major part of America’s affordability crisis, and governors and candidates in red, blue, and purple states are putting forward big plans to make care more affordable for families.

We’ve seen candidates in Georgia campaign on universal pre-K for four-year-olds, in Wisconsin on universal early childhood education for children five and younger, and in Oregon on bringing universal preschool statewide. The list goes on.

The problem is, we don’t all mean the same thing when we say universal.

There’s universal eligibility, where every family qualifies for a publicly funded program, whether that’s pre-K or child care, even if there aren’t enough spots to go around. There’s universal financial assistance, where every family gets some help paying for care, even if they’re still left with a hefty bill. And there’s universal access, where the goal is to make sure every family can actually find a pre-K or child care spot they can afford, with families contributing based on their income.

We tend to lump all these promises together, but they can lead to very different outcomes for families. And with limited funding, providers, and teachers to go around, governors have some important choices to make about what to prioritize, who to serve, and how to reach more families.

Here are three things I’d encourage them to consider before deciding where to invest.

1️⃣ Start with what families in your state need.

Universal pre-K has become a priority for many states. California has rolled out free transitional kindergarten for all four-year-olds, Florida offers free voluntary pre-K for all four-year-olds, and Michigan has expanded its PreK for All program.

I’m all for states making big investments in early childhood education. In doing so, they should ask whether making pre-K universal is where a state’s next dollar will do the most good.

The reality is, there’s only so much money to go around. Even with unlimited funding, we don’t have enough child care providers or qualified teachers to serve every family tomorrow. Governors are going to have to make some tough choices about where to start, and that means getting a good handle on what families in their state need most.

Before deciding where to invest, governors need to get a clear picture of two things:

  • What’s already available? Look at existing early childhood seats and services funded at the regional level by school districts, local governments, or other sources, and identify where families already have access to care.
  • Where are the biggest gaps? Are parents of infants and toddlers struggling to find care? Are certain communities underserved? Is the biggest barrier affordability, or are there not enough providers?

The answers will look different in every state, and they should help determine where the next dollar goes.

2️⃣ Expand access without undermining the child care system you already have.

No single age group or program is going to solve the child care crisis on its own. As governors expand access, they need to think about how investments in one part of the system affect families and providers in another.

With universal pre-K, for example, the way states expand access for four-year-olds could actually make it harder for younger children to find care. Infants and toddlers are more expensive to care for because they require more adults per child. Child care centers often rely on revenue from their four-year-old classrooms to help cover the cost of infant and toddler classrooms. If states move all those four-year-olds into free public school programs, that revenue goes with them, making it harder for centers to keep serving younger children.

You could end up creating more pre-K seats while losing child care spots for infants and toddlers, which is not exactly the outcome we’re looking for.

A better approach is mixed delivery. States can make public pre-K funding available to participating child care centers and community-based programs, not just school districts. Parents still get access to publicly funded pre-K, but they can choose a setting that works for their family, including providers with longer hours or year-round care.

We should be building a portfolio of child care options that meet families’ needs, not expanding one at the expense of another.

3️⃣ Think about how to reach more families with the dollars you have.

Making child care free for every family is an appealing goal, and there’s a lot to like about universal, free programs. They can be simpler to administer, eliminating burdensome income checks and paperwork for families and providers. They also take a major expense off parents’ plates.

But when dollars are limited, there’s a tradeoff. A state could spend a significant amount making care completely free for a smaller group of families, while others continue to struggle to afford it. Or it could use those same dollars to make care more affordable for a larger number of families.

Sliding-scale payments can be a useful option here. Instead of making care completely free for some families while others pay full price, states can ask families to contribute based on what they can afford. Those with the lowest incomes might pay nothing, while families earning more contribute a larger share.

For a family spending a significant share of its income on child care, even cutting that bill in half could be life-changing. And by asking families who can afford to contribute to do so, states may be able to stretch their funding further, helping more families access care and supporting a wider range of providers.

There’s no single right way to structure a universal program. Making child care free for everyone is a worthy ambition, but I’d much rather see states make care meaningfully more affordable for a lot of families than make a promise they can only deliver to a few. After all, calling a program universal doesn’t mean much to a parent who still can’t find a spot or afford the care that’s available.

Start somewhere. Build toward everyone.

Universal child care is a big, expensive undertaking, and no governor is going to get there in a single legislative session–but that doesn’t mean states need to wait until they can afford to make care free for everyone to start expanding access.

Virginia is one state I think has done a good job of getting the ball rolling. Across administrations of both political parties, including under Gov. Glenn Youngkin , Virginia has worked to build a more coordinated early childhood system for children from birth to five, with Jenna Lawrence Conway (now the state’s superintendent) helping lead the effort. The state brought early childhood programs under the Department of Education, established common quality standards across publicly funded programs, and invested in expanding access through both public schools and private providers.

Virginia has also started putting numbers behind what it would take to serve more families, using those figures to make the case for additional funding. It’s not universal child care yet, but the state has a much clearer picture of what it needs to do next.

New York City is also charting a path toward universal child care, starting with its youngest learners. Mayor Zohran Mamdani has set a goal of universal child care from birth to five, and he’s working with Gov. Hochul to make free care available to 2,000 two-year-olds, with plans to reach 12,000 next year. His goal is to reach every family, but he’s starting with what he can deliver now rather than waiting until he can do it all.

Governors and state leaders, take note. Making life more affordable for families in your state starts with making child care more affordable. You don’t have to figure everything out on day one. Whether you’re expanding pre-K for four-year-olds or building toward child care from birth to five, what matters is being clear about what you’re promising families, what it will take to deliver, and how you’ll reach more of them over time. 

Universal is a big promise. Let’s make sure it means something for the families counting on it.

Let’s Get Muddy

For more on early childhood education, check out these previous editions of The Delta:

The Delta. Change is possible.

Follow our newsletter on Linkedin